Authority catalogue v1.13.602 data current as of

Citation
Windsor Framework Art 2(1); s.7A European Union (Withdrawal) Act 2018 (c. 16)
Jurisdiction
Northern Ireland
Year
2020
Status
Primary
Certainty
Evolving

In brief

Article 2(1) of the Windsor Framework requires the United Kingdom to ensure that no diminution of rights, safeguards or equality of opportunity, as set out in the Rights, Safeguards and Equality of Opportunity chapter of the 1998 Belfast (Good Friday) Agreement, results from its withdrawal from the EU, and to implement that commitment through dedicated mechanisms. The commitment expressly includes the area of protection against discrimination as enshrined in the six EU directives listed in Annex 1: the four directives on equal treatment of men and women in goods and services (2004/113/EC), employment and occupation (2006/54/EC), self-employment (2010/41/EU) and social security (79/7/EEC), the racial or ethnic origin directive (2000/43/EC), and the general framework for equal treatment in employment and occupation (2000/78/EC). Section 7A of the European Union (Withdrawal) Act 2018 makes the rights, powers, liabilities, obligations, restrictions, remedies and procedures which, in accordance with the Withdrawal Agreement, are without further enactment to be given legal effect or used in the United Kingdom recognised and available in domestic law, and requires every enactment to be read and have effect subject to them (s.7A(1)-(3)). In In re Dillon [2026] UKSC 15 the Supreme Court held that Article 2(1) can be relied on before a domestic court only if it meets the conditions for direct effect under EU law ([111], [124]), and that the particular provisions of the chapter relied on (paragraphs 1, 11 and 12) cannot have direct effect, even read with Article 2(1) ([114], [125]). It observed that Article 2(1) may be capable of having direct effect in conjunction with other EU instruments within the chapter's ambit, if the Demirel requirements are met, and it agreed with the parties' common position that Article 2(1) might operate with a directly effective provision of an Annex 1 directive, although those directives had no application in the case ([118], [125]). Where Article 2(1) has direct effect, whether there has been a breach is tested in stages: the Court noted that the Court of Appeal had applied a six-stage test adopted from SPUC Pro-Life Ltd v Secretary of State for Northern Ireland [2023] NICA 35 ([69], [127]), and itself applied a three-stage test, proposed by the Secretary of State, which it said essentially covers the same ground: (1) is a right, safeguard or equality of opportunity within the chapter engaged; (2) if so, did it have legal effect in Northern Ireland on 31 December 2020 and was it underpinned by EU law; and (3) was there a diminution of it as a result of the United Kingdom's withdrawal from the EU ([126]-[128]). Because it was not material to the outcome of the appeal which approach was followed, the Court applied the three-stage test without choosing between them ([128]).

Status and dates

The Protocol on Ireland/Northern Ireland was published in the Official Journal of the European Union on 31 January 2020 as a protocol to be annexed to the Withdrawal Agreement. It is now formally known as the Windsor Framework, following revised arrangements agreed between the United Kingdom and the EU that took effect on 24 March 2023 (Dillon [6]). Joint Committee Decision No 1/2023, adopted on 24 March 2023 as part of those arrangements and in force from the following day (Article 23(1), (2)), amended Article 6(2) and Annex 3 and added a new Article 13(3a), which covers only the Union acts referred to in the first indent of heading 1 and headings 7 to 47 of Annex 2, and the third subparagraph of Article 5(1); it did not amend Article 2 or Annex 1 (Decision No 1/2023, Articles 1 to 4). Section 7A was inserted into the European Union (Withdrawal) Act 2018 by the European Union (Withdrawal Agreement) Act 2020 with effect from 31 January 2020. The comparison date for any alleged diminution is 31 December 2020, when the transition period ended (Dillon [69], [128]). In [2024] NIKB 35 (13 May 2024), an earlier first-instance application of Article 2, the High Court in Northern Ireland followed the first-instance judgment in the Dillon proceedings ([45]-[46], [69]-[70], [181]), read the reference to the civil rights of everyone in the community broadly ([68]-[70]), applied the six-stage SPUC test ([73], [175]) and disapplied provisions of the Illegal Migration Act 2023 in Northern Ireland ([182]). Its current appellate position should be checked before relying on it. In In re Dillon [2026] UKSC 15 (7 May 2026) the Supreme Court allowed the Secretary of State's appeal on the Windsor Framework ground ([139], [250]). It settled that reliance on Article 2(1) depends on the EU-law conditions for direct effect ([111], [124]), read the reference to civil rights in paragraph 1 of the chapter as appearing to refer at a general level to civil and political rights, the listed examples of which are concerned with ending sectarian conflict ([119], [131]), and applied a three-stage breach test while leaving open the choice between that test and the six-stage test ([127]-[128]). It did not decide whether or how a court must disapply legislation for breach of Article 2(1) ([138]). Dillon does not refer to [2024] NIKB 35, but its reading of the chapter is narrower than the one adopted there, and the earlier judgment should be read in that light. Caution: whether Article 2(1) affects how Northern Ireland's own equality legislation is to be read after For Women Scotland Ltd v The Scottish Ministers [2025] UKSC 16 is contested and should be treated as open. No conclusion on that question should be drawn from Article 2(1) or from Dillon, which did not concern the Annex 1 directives ([118]).

Key provisions

When relevant

Cite when assessing whether a law, policy or practice in Northern Ireland reduces a right, safeguard or equality of opportunity that was underpinned by EU law at the end of 2020, particularly protection against discrimination under the six Annex 1 equality directives. Also relevant when considering whether Great Britain equality case law, including For Women Scotland Ltd v The Scottish Ministers [2025] UKSC 16, can safely be relied on in Northern Ireland; that question is contested and should be treated as open.

Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.