Authority catalogue v1.13.602 data current as of

Citation
Case C-247/23, ECLI:EU:C:2025:172
Jurisdiction
EU
Year
2025
Status
Persuasive
Certainty
Evolving

In brief

The Court of Justice (First Chamber) held that Article 16 of the GDPR requires a national authority that keeps a public register to rectify personal data relating to a person's gender identity where those data are inaccurate within the meaning of the accuracy principle in Article 5(1)(d) (operative part, point 1). Accuracy is assessed in the light of the purpose for which the data were collected; where that purpose is to identify the person, the data would appear to refer to the person's lived gender identity and not to the identity assigned to them at birth, a matter the Court left to the national court to check ([26], [32]). A Member State may restrict the right to rectification only by a legislative measure that meets the conditions of Article 23 GDPR, and it cannot rely on the absence in its national law of a procedure for the legal recognition of transgender identity to limit that right ([34]-[37]). The person seeking rectification may be required to provide relevant and sufficient evidence that can reasonably be required of them to show that the data are inaccurate, but a Member State may not, under any circumstances, by way of an administrative practice, make rectification conditional on evidence of gender reassignment surgery (operative part, point 2). In its reasoning the Court found that such a practice is not a legislative measure, undermines the essence of the rights to integrity of the person and to respect for private life under Articles 3 and 7 of the Charter, and is in any event neither necessary nor proportionate to keeping a public register reliable and consistent ([44]-[49]).

Status and dates

Reference from the Fővárosi Törvényszék (Budapest High Court, Hungary) by decision of 29 March 2023, received 18 April 2023; hearing 3 June 2024; Opinion of Advocate General Collins delivered 12 September 2024; judgment of the First Chamber, presided over by the President of the Court, 13 March 2025 (ECLI:EU:C:2025:172). The case name Deldits is fictitious; the proceedings were between VP and the Országos Idegenrendészeti Főigazgatóság (National Directorate-General for Immigration Policing). Three questions were referred: whether Article 16 requires rectification of gender data that have changed since they were entered in the register, whether the person seeking rectification must provide evidence, and whether they must prove gender reassignment surgery ([21]). The Court reformulated the first ([22]) and answered the second and third together, recast around a Member State's administrative practice ([39]). The referring court stated that Hungarian law laid down no procedure for refugees to obtain recognition of a change of gender identity, despite a 2018 Constitutional Court ruling and the 2020 Strasbourg judgment in Rana v Hungary, and that since 2020 such recognition had ceased to be possible for Hungarian nationals as well ([19]-[20]). The judgment relies on Mirin (C-4/23, 4 October 2024): by analogy at [37], and for the Charter and Article 8 ECHR case law at [46]-[47]. It was later cited by the Court in Shipova (C-43/24, Second Chamber, 12 March 2026), at [50], for [47]-[48] on Article 8 ECHR and gender identity. Status in UK law: the judgment was given after 31 December 2020, so it does not bind UK courts; a UK court may have regard to it so far as relevant (European Union (Withdrawal) Act 2018, s.6(1)(a) and (2)). It interprets the EU GDPR, not any of the equality directives listed in Annex 1 to the Windsor Framework.

Key provisions

When relevant

Cite as persuasive authority when handling a request to correct a gender marker held about a person under UK GDPR Article 16, which is worded identically to the provision the Court interpreted (the power to restrict that right in UK GDPR Article 23 is worded differently from the EU text). The Court ruled only on data relating to gender identity, not on the forename change VP also sought ([16]) or on titles; whether the reasoning extends to them is open. Accuracy is assessed against the purpose for which the data were collected ([26], [32]). A controller may ask for relevant and sufficient evidence that can reasonably be required in the circumstances of the case to show the data are inaccurate; a condition going beyond that, such as the surgery-evidence practice at issue, is a restriction of the right that must comply with Article 23: a legislative measure that respects the essence of the fundamental rights and is necessary and proportionate ([41]-[44]). On evidence of surgery, the Court held that a Member State may not, by administrative practice, make rectification of data in a public register conditional on evidence of gender reassignment surgery ([50], operative part, point 2); it did not rule on legislative requirements or on private controllers, though its reasoning on the essence of the Charter rights ([45]) and on proportionality ([49]) may bear on them. It does not bind UK courts and says nothing about the meaning of sex under the Equality Act 2010.